YFYS performance test ignores actual returns

your future your super YFYS superannuation Frontier fees

4 March 2021
| By Jassmyn |
image
image
expand image

The Your Future Your Super (YFYS) superannuation performance test ignores actual returns, does not incorporate most risk adjusted improvements from diversified exposures, and excludes administration fees, according to Frontier.

In its submission to the YFYS reform consultation, Frontier said that, while the Government’s goal was to hold funds to account for underperformance, its reform would allow funds to underperform for seven to eight years before action, and the performance test was not directly related to members’ outcomes.

This would allow funds to gouge members on administration fees and be detrimental to disengaged members.

Specifically, Frontier said the performance test:

  • Assessed how well a fund had implemented its chosen strategy, not whether it was a good strategy;
  • Ignored actual returns and the CPI+ objectives of funds that reflected long-term member outcomes;
  • Did not incorporate most risk adjusted improvements for more diversified exposures;
  • Was not a peer relative assessment of underperformance; and
  • Excluded administration fees, which had meaningful impact on members’ outcomes.

“Funds will need to work out how to consider this test alongside existing investment objectives and in the context of their investment philosophy,” Frontier said.

“As the test represents a new regulatory risk, a key step is understanding how portfolios are positioned relative to this new benchmark.

“As the test only captures part of the investment strategy, is assessed over a shorter timeframe than existing objectives, and the listed benchmark selection for some asset classes embeds a higher risk into the benchmark, there is a likelihood that portfolios well positioned to meet their long-term objectives and member needs could underperform the test from time to time.”

The submission said the performance test and a comparison tool could better meet the policy with enhancements including:

  • Ensuring the performance test and the comparison tool are aligned, so consumers do not receive conflicting information;
  • As the test with the greatest consequence of failure, we believe the performance test should be the most comprehensive assessment. A single test made up of a well-designed collection of multiple metrics is likely to be more effective and reliable than a single metric based on a narrow assessment of quality;
  • As MySuper products are meant to be simple and low-cost, we believe both investment and administration all fees should be included. This is in line with the Productivity Commission (PC) analysis;
  • In line with the PC recommendation, we believe that APRA should play a key role in working with funds which failure the performance test to improve or exit. This should provide more timely protection for consumers rather than relying on member engagement;
  • Many funds invest in unlisted assets for diversification and risk-reduction, rather than additional returns. Better recognise these risk-reducing benefits by using blended benchmarks; and
  • In line with the PC recommendation, we believe that the performance test and comparison tool should apply to all investment options, rather than just MySuper options.
Read more about:

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

MARKET INSIGHTS

This verdict highlights something deeply wrong and rotten at the heart of the FSCP. We are witnessing a heavy-handed, op...

1 hour ago

Interesting. Would be good to know the details of the StrategyOne deal....

4 days 6 hours ago

It’s astonishing to see the FAAA now pushing for more advisers by courting "career changers" and international recruits,...

3 weeks 2 days ago

Insignia Financial has made four appointments, including three who have joined from TAL, to lead strategy and innovation in its retirement solutions for the MLC brand....

2 weeks 4 days ago

A former Brisbane financial adviser has been charged with 26 counts of dishonest conduct regarding a failure to disclose he would receive substantial commission payments ...

3 days 4 hours ago

Pinnacle Investment Management has announced it will acquire strategic interests in two international fund managers for $142 million....

2 days 7 hours ago