SG: One size does not fit all say academics

14 January 2020
| By Mike |
image
image
expand image

At the same time as the Government prepares to embark on its Retirement Income Review, new modelling from the Australian National University (ANU) has suggested lifting the superannuation guarantee (SG) needs to be based on a firm decision about the purpose of superannuation as a pension replacement.

The modelling suggests that lifting the SG from the current 9.5% to 12% can be justified if the policy objective involves either replacing the Age Pension or requiring members to self-insure against various risks.

The modelling, undertaken by Guarav Khemka, Yifu Tang and Geoff Warren from ANU’s College of Business and Economics, and the authors stated that one of the key findings of their research was that there was no single SG level that would suit all and it raised questions about whether it made sense to require everyone to save more by imposing a higher SG just because it suited some.

They said that it was in these circumstances the Government needed to specify the objective of superannuation – “whether the aim is to replace the Age Pension where possible”.

The authors also argue that a decision needed to be made about how to trade-off gains and losses between members stating:  “The variable impact of the SG across members should be addressed, noting we find that an increase could be relatively detrimental for low income earners once the Age Pension and tax impacts are considered”.

They also noted “asymmetry between setting the SG higher versus lower in circumstances where “members can do nothing if the SG is set too high, but can contribute more if it is set too low”.

“However, the idea of retaining a lower SG for flexibility might be balanced against the reluctance to contribute beyond the mandated minimum,” it said.

Read more about:

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

MARKET INSIGHTS

GG

So shareholders lose a dividend plus have seen the erosion of value. Qantas decides to clawback remuneration from Alan ...

2 months 1 week ago
Denise Baker

This is why I left my last position. There was no interest in giving the client quality time, it was all about bumping ...

2 months 1 week ago
gonski

So the Hayne Royal Commission has left us with this. What a sad day for the financial planning industry. Clearly most ...

2 months 1 week ago

A Sydney-based financial adviser has been banned from providing financial services in the interest of consumer protection after failing to act on conduct concerns. ...

3 weeks 3 days ago

ASIC has cancelled the AFSL of a $250 million Sydney fund manager, one of two AFSL cancellations announced by the corporate regulator....

3 weeks 1 day ago

Having divested its advice business in August, AMP is undergoing restructuring in at least four other departments amid a cost simplification program....

2 weeks 5 days ago