Retirement Incomes: advantages and disadvantages

interest rates capital gains

12 October 2005
| By Carmen Watts |

Lifetime annuity

Advantages:

~ income is guaranteed for life

~ income may be indexed for inflation (at a rate of 3.0% pa), so purchasing power is not eroded by increased living costs

~ low exposure to investment risk

~ annuity purchase price attracts a 50% exemption under Centrelink’s Asset Test

~ income is Centrelink friendly, as a significant portion is not assessed under Centrelink’s income test

~ income is tax effective, as it includes a tax deductible amount and attracts a 15% pension rebate on the assessable income amount

~ where a reversionary pensioner has been nominated (eg, a spouse), they may choose to continue to receive regular pension payments, or commute the remaining capital to a lump sum

~ where pensioners die before the end of the guarantee period, the value of the remaining payments will be paid to their estate

Disadvantages:

~ no access to capital invested (ie, the annuity is non-commutable)

~ returns linked to prevailing interest rates at time of investment; if interest rates increase, pensioner will not benefit from higher income returns (if

interest rates fall, pensioner will benefit from higher interest returns).

~ income payments do not vary to reflect investment market performance

~ where pensioners die after the guarantee period, any entitlement to income or capital is forfeited (unless a reversionary pension has been nominated)

Term annuity

Advantages:

~ income is guaranteed for the term of the annuity

~ income is indexed for inflation (at a rate of 3.0% pa), so purchasing power is not eroded by increased living costs

~ low exposure to investment risk

~ annuity purchase price attracts a 50% exemption under Centrelink’s Asset Test

~ income is Centrelink friendly, as a significant portion is not assessed under Centrelink’s income test

~ income is tax effective as it includes a tax deductible amount and attracts a 15% pension rebate on the assessable income amount

~ where a reversionary pensioner has been nominated (eg, a spouse), they may choose to continue to receive regular pension payments, or commute the remaining capital to a lump sum

~ where pensioners die before the end of the guarantee period, the value of the remaining payments will be paid to their estate

Disadvantages

~ no access to capital invested (ie, the annuity is non-commutable)

~ returns linked to prevailing interest rates at time of investment; if interest rates increase, pensioner will not benefit from higher income returns (similarly, if interest rates fall, pensioner will benefit from securing higher interest returns).

~ income payments do not vary to reflect investment market performance

Allocated pensions

Advantages:

~ investment earnings on capital are tax-free

~ no capital gains tax paid for any capital realised — only drawn income is taxable

~ capital can be accessed at any time by making lump sum withdrawals (which are subject to ETP withdrawal tax)

~ income is tax effective; undeducted contributions will include a “tax-free” income component

~ income not received “tax-free” will be taxed at the marginal tax rate, however pensioners receive a 15% tax rebate

~ these are Centrelink friendly investments, as a significant portion of income is exempt from Centrelink’s Income Test

~ capital is not lost on death; balance can be paid to dependants, or in

accordance with will or estate

~ where a reversionary pensioner has been nominated (eg, a spouse), they may choose to continue to receive regular pension payments, or commute the remaining capital to a lump sum

Disadvantages:

~ income received will include a Centrelink deductible amount, but the account balance will be assessed under Centrelink’s Asset test

~ income payments not guaranteed; payments continue only until account balance runs out; account balance will depend on the performance of the underlying assets and the level of income the pensioner elects to receive

Term allocated pensions

Advantages:

~ tested under the pension RBL — allows a greater super benefit to be

concessionally treated

~ treated concessionally under the Assets Test for Social Security — 50% of purchase price/account value not counted

~ The pension term can be selected by the primary pensioner from a range of different terms; this gives more flexibility to choose a term closely aligned to the pensioner's needs

Disadvantages:

~ no guarantee of investment performance — in a negative investment climate, the annual payment could fall to reflect negative returns

~ the pensioner cannot select an annual pension amount — only one amount can be paid pa, according to statutory payment factors applying

~ no fixed annual income amount — both the changing value of the account and each new financial year’s payment factor will usually see a changing annual payment from year to year

~ limited recourse to a lump sum withdrawal

~ no guarantee that the pension will last as long as the life of the primary beneficiary

~ no provision for a residual capital value upon the death of the last survivor

Read more about:

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

MARKET INSIGHTS

Completely agree Peter. The definition of 'significant change is circumstances relevant to the scope of the advice' is s...

3 weeks ago

This verdict highlights something deeply wrong and rotten at the heart of the FSCP. We are witnessing a heavy-handed, op...

3 weeks 5 days ago

Interesting. Would be good to know the details of the StrategyOne deal....

1 month ago

Insignia Financial has confirmed it is considering a preliminary non-binding proposal received from a US private equity giant to acquire the firm. ...

5 days 19 hours ago

Six of the seven listed financial advice licensees have reported positive share price growth in 2024, with AMP and Insignia successfully reversing earlier losses. ...

1 day 10 hours ago

A former Brisbane financial adviser has been charged with 26 counts of dishonest conduct regarding a failure to disclose he would receive substantial commission payments ...

4 weeks 1 day ago