Brogden lambasts super critics on old information

chief executive financial services council FSC cooper review

8 August 2014
| By Mike |
image
image
expand image

Critics of the Australian superannuation system including with respect to its tax concessional status, have been guilty of using outdated and inaccurate data, according to Financial Services Council (FSC) chief executive, John Brogden.

In his address to the FSC conference in Cairns, Brogden singled out recent reports produced by the Grattan Institute and the Financial System Inquiry for their failings.

"In recent months, two reports — one from the think tank, the Grattan Institute and the other from the Financial System Inquiry — have weighed in with commentary, opinion and observation," he said. "Both have based much on research and data to support and prove their arguments. Sadly, neither have used vigorous or accurate data and in the area of international comparisons, both failed to recognise fundamental important, unique and individual features of the Australian superannuation system."

Brogden said the two most common mistakes had been comparing Australia's fully-funded defined contribution system to unfunded defined benefit schemes in Europe.

"These schemes have totally different asset allocation and return profiles. Australia also differs due to the large amount of assets in individual accounts within the self managed sector," he said. "It also ignores the fact that Australia's superannuation system is full service."

"The administration cost component for the average superannuation fund is 0.40 per cent. The services offered by Australian superannuation funds are vastly different to European DB schemes which don't offer any of these services. Essentially the data does not compare ‘like with like'," the FSC chief executive said.

Further, he claimed that old data was being widely used with most of the information used in the public debate being "pre-MySuper and draws on porous OECD data from 2009. And some of the statements on fees come from the Cooper Review in 2010, which led to the creation of MySuper".

Read more about:

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

MARKET INSIGHTS

Completely agree Peter. The definition of 'significant change is circumstances relevant to the scope of the advice' is s...

3 weeks 5 days ago

This verdict highlights something deeply wrong and rotten at the heart of the FSCP. We are witnessing a heavy-handed, op...

1 month ago

Interesting. Would be good to know the details of the StrategyOne deal....

1 month ago

Insignia Financial has confirmed it is considering a preliminary non-binding proposal received from a US private equity giant to acquire the firm. ...

1 week 3 days ago

Six of the seven listed financial advice licensees have reported positive share price growth in 2024, with AMP and Insignia successfully reversing earlier losses. ...

6 days 6 hours ago

Specialist wealth platform provider Mason Stevens has become the latest target of an acquisition as it enters a binding agreement with a leading Sydney-based private equi...

5 days 10 hours ago