Stock quality more important than investment style
Investors should focus instead on quality and an intersection of growth and value to get ‘quality at a reasonable price’, according to DNR Capital.
The firm’s recent study on ‘Qualifying Value and Growth’ showed that the history of the stock market saw periods where both styles – growth and value – had been in and out of favour, even though growth stocks outperformed value counterparts to unprecedented levels since the Global Financial Crisis (GFC).
Therefore, DNR said, it was important in assessing portfolio exposure to understand different categories of both value and growth investing, with different opportunities and risk profiles.
“In informing DNR Capital’s investment strategy, this debate is a constructive lens through which to assess the broader market, but quality remains the core of our philosophy. We explore how a balanced approach to selecting the highest quality stocks delivers sustainable performance, without anchoring portfolios to a blind commitment to one style,” DNR Capital’s chief investment officer, Jamie Nicol, said.
The key takeaways from a study with UBS Quant and Strategy, which explored the quality measures, were:
- The cheapest quintile of value stock actually underperformed the market significantly;
- The growth factor produced highly inconsistent results with the second lowest and second highest growth baskets outperforming only;
- Quality provided more consistent outcomes with the lowest quality basket significantly underperforming, while the highest and second highest quality baskets outperformed; and
- The largest underperformance across the entire study was from lowest quality basket.
“Exceptionally high-quality stocks are uncommon, require detailed and rigorous research to validate, and at times fall into either growth and/or value classifications. Economic cycles and the machinations of the market means both value and growth styles have their time in the sun,” Nicol said.
“We conclude that in this current environment of extremes, it is prudent to fall back on our process and philosophy of balance, without an overarching anchor to value or growth, but always with a strong bias towards quality.”
AUTHOR
Oksana Patron
Recommended for you
Schroders has appointed a new chief executive as Simon Doyle steps down from the asset manager after 22 years.
Distribution of private credit funds through advised channels to retail investors will be an ASIC priority for 2026 as it releases the results of its thematic fund surveillance and guidance for research houses.
State Street Investment Management has taken a minority stake in private market secondaries manager Coller Capital with the pair set to collaborate on broaden each firm’s reach and drive innovation.
BlackRock Australia plans to launch a Bitcoin ETF later this month, wrapping the firm’s US-listed version which is US$85 billion in size.
