Morningstar claims fund managers lack skill

morningstar australian equities property international equities asset classes fund manager

29 April 2004
| By Jason |

Managed funds research houseMorningstaris claiming managed funds are able to beat any given benchmark but few do so, due to a lack of manager skill.

Morningstar conducted the study after being commissioned byVanguard Investmentsand used its own data to identify managers which beat the index and demonstrate some skill to do so.

However Morningstar states that skill is a subjective term and can be measured using qualitative and quantitative measures and its study applied a statistical test to measure how often funds added value above an index for five and seven year periods to the end of June 2003.

In releasing the study findings today Morningstar says it calculated manager skill by the level of excess returns over a particular benchmark and the consistency at which this took place.

The study says retail Australian equities funds were the most dominant example of its core premise that many funds can beat a benchmark but few to do with skill, with 61 per cent of funds beating the benchmark, but only 4 per cent demonstrating skill in doing so.

Morningstar head of consulting Anthony Serhan says a measure of skill is the level of outperformance a fund achieves above benchmark stating that 52 per cent of wholesale listed property funds have beaten the index.

However Serhan says the outperformance was very low and was not possible to state it showed any skill or would be repeatable by the fund manager with only two of the listed property funds in the study generating excesses above 1 per cent per annum.

The study also found that excess returns increased as the level of risk increased in an asset class with Australian equities funds beating the index most often followed by international equities, and then Australian fixed interest.

As a result Morningstar says the benefits of selecting the best performing managers varies between asset classes but is reduced in the Australian fixed interest sector compared with Australian equities.

“The study shows clearly that it’s more difficult to add value in some asset classes than others. This highlights the dangers in drawing conclusions from simple return figures. A return figure tells you where the fund finished — it doesn't tell you how the race was run,” Serhan says.

The study results are based on an examination of 316 retail and wholesale funds in Australian equities, international equities, Australian listed property, and Australian fixed interest which had a minimum five year performance track record.

The fund returns were net of ongoing expenses and were compared with an unadjusted capital market index return for each sector, while information ratios were based on the fund’s excess returns divided by the tracking error over the relevant period.

Morningstar considered ‘skill’ for returns to be a managed fund which had a positive information ratio and a monthly excess return (over the five or seven years to 30 June 2003) greater than zero at the 95 per cent confidence level.

Read more about:

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

MARKET INSIGHTS

Completely agree Peter. The definition of 'significant change is circumstances relevant to the scope of the advice' is s...

3 weeks 5 days ago

This verdict highlights something deeply wrong and rotten at the heart of the FSCP. We are witnessing a heavy-handed, op...

1 month ago

Interesting. Would be good to know the details of the StrategyOne deal....

1 month ago

Insignia Financial has confirmed it is considering a preliminary non-binding proposal received from a US private equity giant to acquire the firm. ...

1 week 3 days ago

Six of the seven listed financial advice licensees have reported positive share price growth in 2024, with AMP and Insignia successfully reversing earlier losses. ...

6 days 8 hours ago

Specialist wealth platform provider Mason Stevens has become the latest target of an acquisition as it enters a binding agreement with a leading Sydney-based private equi...

5 days 12 hours ago