Majority of hedge funds not delivering on their promise
Only 30 per cent of institutional investors' hedge fund portfolios outperform simple investible benchmarks as fees make hedge fund portfolios ‘bad investments' with net alpha of -1.88 per cent, according to CEM Benchmarking.
Its recent study analysed realised hedge funds portfolio returns of over 300 large global investors and found that for most funds, with return histories exceeding five years, the performance could be replicated at much lower cost by simple equity/debt blends.
The study also proved that many funds were promised superior uncorrelated returns, but they received neither .The average correlation to simple stock/bond portfolios was 84 per cent, and for over half of funds correlations exceeded 90 per cent.
Senior research analyst and lead author of the study, Alexander Beath, said that most hedge fund portfolios looked "surprisingly like simple stock/bond portfolios".
"I think the most surprising part of the study is just how much of the return of hedge funds can be replicated by simple holding a 50/50 stock/bond portfolio. Hedge funds are often compared to equity indices, but this isn't appropriate. The risk and correlations in hedge funds lies somewhere between stock and bonds, and so this is what they should be compared to"
Additionally, the study also analysed each hedge fund portfolio separately, finding the optimal risk-matched investable portfolio for each with the on average split to be 44 per cent equity and 56 per cent fixed income with a duration of over five years, which was not far from vanilla 50/50 portfolios.
The percentage of hedge fund portfolios that managed to outperform the investable index included the following features:
- Funds with long histories investing in hedge funds tended to outperform those with short histories;
- Funds with lower correlation to equity/debt blends tended to outperform those with high correlations; and
- Funds with low cost implementation tended to outperform those with high cost implementation .
AUTHOR
Oksana Patron
Recommended for you
LGT Wealth Management is maintaining a neutral stance on US equities going into 2026 as it is worried whether the hype around AI euphoria will continue.
Tyndall Asset Management is to close down the Tyndall brand and launch a newly-branded affiliate following a “material change” to its client base.
First Sentier has launched its second active ETF, offering advisers an ETF version of its Ex-20 Australian Share strategy.
BlackRock has revealed that its iShares bitcoin ETF suite has now become the firm’s most profitable product line following the launch of its Australian bitcoin ETF last month.
