The ‘fake’ alpha derived from low carbon strategies
Using low carbon strategies reduces portfolio performance and can lead to problems with concentration and investability, according to Scientific Beta.
The research organisation said investors were mistakenly using low carbon strategies as a way to add alpha to their performance.
In its research paper, When Greenness is Mistaken for Alpha: Pitfalls in Constructing Low Carbon Equity Portfolios, it said using low carbon could also add higher costs.
“Constructing portfolios using low carbon scores like any other alpha score does not improve performance and leads to problems with concentration and investability,” it said.
“The costs borne by investors who build portfolios with a mistaken belief in a positive low carbon alpha are substantial. Multi-factor portfolios that impose positive weights on the low carbon factor have an inferior risk-return profile: A low carbon allocation of 40% leads to a poorly factor-diversified portfolio and as a direct consequence gives up 100bp of annualised returns on a risk-adjusted basis.”
If investors were set on using these type of strategies, the firm said, it should consider how much the strategy would help them hedge climate risks or make a positive impact on corporate behaviour.
Dr Noel Amenc, chief executive of Scientific Beta, said: “The pressing issue faced by society is tackling climate change, not generating alpha. And while low carbon alpha appears to be fake, the damage from climate change unfortunately is real”.
AUTHOR
Laura Dew
Recommended for you
Index provider MSCI has unveiled two measures to make it easier for financial advisers and wealth managers to access transparent insights into private assets.
Vanguard has announced a strategic alliance with two US alternative asset managers to develop multi-asset solutions for financial advisers which combine public and private markets.
Clime Investment Management has enacted a range of growth initiatives to boost the firm’s reach with wholesale investors and a new approach targeting the retail market.
Generation Development Group, parent of Generation Life, has entered the ASX 200, having grown its funds under management to almost $4 billion.
