Beware poor ESG in passive funds
Investors in passive emerging markets funds need to be wary of being invested in companies with poor environmental and social governance standards (ESG), according to Stewart Investors manager Jack Nelson.
Opting for an index or exchange traded fund (ETF) meant investors followed the benchmark which could typically contain large multi-nationals which did not always adhere to the best standards.
Nelson, who manages the Stewart Investors Wholesale Global Emerging Markets Sustainability fund, said: “It is difficult to screen for quality companies in a passive fund. Without taking an active approach then you can end up misallocated into bad companies.”
Many of the companies that scored poorly from an ESG perspective were state-owned enterprises, those companies where the state was the majority shareholder, a practice that was particularly big in countries such as Brazil, China and South Africa.
This state ownership then led to a misalignment between the strategic interest of the state and those of minority shareholders. However, they generally tended to have lower risk than the wider market as they were backed by the government and had higher dividend yields.
Nelson said financial and resources companies were also sectors which tended to score poorly on ESG standards.
Emerging market companies tended to score lower overall than their developed market counterparts on factors such as board, ownership and control and pay and accounting practices.
This was worsened, Nelson said, by the fact there was often limited corporate transparency or disclosure at emerging market companies which made them harder for managers to assess.
“There have been issues of corruption, the interactions between management and politicians can undo businesses and we have seen that repeatedly over the years. Also resources companies have had environmental disasters which make us wary,” he said.
“We are trying to find high quality companies run by people we can trust, which are resilient to change and financed in a conservative way.”
The Stewart Investors Wholesale Global Emerging Markets Sustainability fund has returned 9.1 per cent over one year to 19 August, according to FE Analytics, versus returns of 6.4 per cent by the ACS Equity-Emerging Markets sector.
AUTHOR
Laura Dew
Recommended for you
There has been a “noticeable uptick” in the use of smart beta ETFs by advisers and sophisticated investors, according to Betashares, who are using the vehicles to take control of their portfolio construction.
The FSC has announced 15 proposals ahead of the federal election which it hopes will increase the competitiveness of Australia’s financial services sector, including six with a focus on fund managers.
Regal Funds Management saw total net inflows of $2.1 billion during 2024, with flows primarily going into long/short equities and multistrategy vehicles.
There is growing divergence between institutional and retail investors in their enthusiasm towards equities, according to Bank of America, with retail sentiment being “unusually low” at the start of 2025.
