Whistleblowers’ mental illness used to discredit them
Organisations demonise whistleblowers and depict them as mentally ill in an attempt to discredit their claims, according to new UK research.
A paper from the University of Warwick Business School found whistleblowers lost their jobs either through dismissal or by being pressured out of the firm, while those who stayed faced bullying, demotion, and harassment. Others were forced to attend mental health counselling by their company.
This has led to some suffering depression, panic attacks, and anxiety, while others developed drinking issues.
Warwick Business School's Marianna Fotaki said the mental health issues of whistleblowers could be used to discredit their allegations, while diverting attention away from the information revealed by them.
"The stigma surrounding mental illness can be used as a weapon intended to defame and neutralise a person who discloses wrongdoing, with the process of whistleblowing only intensifying the likelihood of experiencing such negative health effects," Fotaki said.
The paper, titled ‘How Organisations Use Mental Health to Discipline Whistleblowers and Undermine their Message', interviewed 25 whistleblowers from the UK, Europe, and the US, and found all 25 respondents faced retaliation from the firms either through isolation, demotion, or termination of employment.
No organisation was grateful for the whistleblower bringing wrongdoings to the fore, nor did they attempt to remedy the wrongdoings. Instead they went into denial and demonised the whistleblower.
One whistleblower saw his organisation commission a report into his complaint but the report was about the whistleblower rather than the firm's wrongdoing, and it described him as "emotional and not reasoned, measured or coherent".
Recommended for you
ASIC data shows the number of smaller AFSLs with less than $50 million in revenue has increased by 25 per cent in the past year, but the regulator believes they are still under reporting breaches.
Former financial adviser and Coalition backbencher Bert van Manen has introduced a bill in Parliament, building on Michelle Levy’s good advice duty and calling for SOAs to be scrapped.
Following its recent partnership with Otivo, Colonial First State has now announced an arrangement with Viridian Advisory to offer unadvised members with one-off, topic-based financial advice.
Insignia Financial has made four appointments, including three who have joined from TAL, to lead strategy and innovation in its retirement solutions for the MLC brand.