SMSFs fine without advisers, study finds
Research commissioned by Vanguard and the SMSF Professionals' Association of Australia (SPAA) has exposed the failure of advisers to improve the financial strength of self-managed super fund (SMSF) members' account balances.
A Rice Warner survey of SPAA and Vanguard trustees could not identify a clear relationship between the use of financial advice and the performance of their SMSF, with unhappy trustees accusing advisers of having less knowledge of complex SMSF issues than the SMSF members themselves.
According to the survey, the average performance for SMSFs was the same - at 11.1 or 11.2 per cent - regardless of whether SMSF trustees relied on advisers, accountants or researching newspapers and books for their information.
Forty-three per cent of respondents use a planner for their main source of financial information, while just over 40 per cent rely on financial newspapers, magazines or books.
The research found 31.5 per cent use the internet and nearly 52 per cent of respondents use accountants or tax specialists.
Members also accused advisers are being more interested in product pushing than client returns, or cited the lack of adviser contact as a concern.
Rice Warner chief executive Michael Rice agreed that one reason for the lack of correlation between SMSF returns and advice was that people were relying on their own education rather than an expert, but added that investors also had assets outside super, and an SMSF only comprised one part of a portfolio.
Sixty-six per cent of respondents said their adviser met their expectations, while 34 per cent were unsatisfied with the advice received.
Rice cautioned that the issue needed to be looked at again in future.
SPAA chief executive Andrea Slattery said that SMSF investors weren't necessarily seeking complex advice every time they saw a planner, but a holistic flexible strategy, including compliance and improving investors' education.
The research also found unrealistic expectations of income needs, with 27 per cent of respondents believing they would have more than $100,000 of annual income in retirement.
It was unrealistic if you considered that members lived for 30 to 40 years after retirement, Rice said.
Recommended for you
While returns and fees are the top priority for older Australians when it comes to their superannuation, more than one in 10 are calling for access to tailored financial advice.
Determinations by the FSCP since the start of 2025 are almost double the number in the same period of 2024, with non-concessional contribution cap errors and incorrect advice among the issues.
Whether received via human or digital means, financial advice is reportedly leading to lower stress and more confidence, according to Vanguard.
The new financial year has got off to a strong start in adviser gains, helped by new entrants, after heavy losses sustained in June.
