Secret campaign targets industry funds
A major retail fund manager, owned by one of Australia’s largest banks, has launched a clandestine marketing campaign to help financial planners debunk industry funds’ advertising claims at the point of client contact.
The fund manager has been distributing the campaign in ‘closed’ sessions at seminars and conferences of its aligned dealer groups this year, as well as those of other non-aligned dealer groups.
Financial planners from both an institution-owned and an independently-owned dealer group told Money Management in confidence that they attended one of these closed sessions this year.
The planners said the campaign message was delivered via a representative of the fund manager - the name of which is known to Money Management - using a PowerPoint presentation entitled ‘Industry Fund Myths Exposed’.
They said the presentation used comprehensive research to debunk what was described as “six very damaging myths spread by the industry funds in its current ‘Compare the Pair’ advertising campaign”.
“It accused the industry funds of cleverly leveraging the government, the regulators and media to spread these myths on their make-up and performance, without ever having to reveal the truth behind them.
“In particular, the industry funds were accused of spending $65 million in advertising — funded by the savings of their members — purely to attack the retail superannuation and financial planning sectors.”
The planners said the campaign concluded by “calling on the whole financial planning community to use its influence to correct the inaccurate perception being created by industry funds”.
“The presenter described the presentation as a ‘call to action’ to spread the word, to fight back against these myths, in the media and with our clients,” they said.
One of the planners also said he understood the campaign had been launched by the fund manager only after sustained pressure from within its aligned dealer groups to counter the industry fund advertising claims.
He said there were demands for the fund manager to sponsor a national advertising campaign to counter the industry funds’ claims but it refused to do so for fear of losing substantial wholesale mandates from the industry funds.
In the end, as a compromise, the fund manager launched the clandestine marketing campaign as a way of trying to exert pressure on the industry funds while remaining anonymous, he said.
Recommended for you
Sequoia Financial Group has declined by five financial advisers in the past week, four of whom have opened up a new AFSL, according to Wealth Data.
Insignia Financial chief executive Scott Hartley has detailed whether the firm will be selecting an exclusive bidder for the second phase of due diligence as it awaits revised bids from three private equity players.
Insignia Financial has reported a statutory net loss after tax of $17 million in its first half results, although the firm has noted cost optimisation means this is an improvement from a $50 million loss last year.
With alternative funds being described as “impossible” for fund managers to target towards advisers without the support of BDMs for education, Money Management explores the evolving nature of the distribution role.
