Research debunks index argument

australian equities fund manager

12 June 2001
| By Lachlan Gilbert |

Research by Partnership Planning debunks the notion put out by index managers that actively managed funds do not consistently outperform the index, even after the higher fees are subtracted from the returns.

Partnership Planning head of research, Lynne Curtis, says the research found that the median Australian equities fund manager has consistently outperformed the All Ordianries index.

"The index approach says active managers can't consistently outperform the index. We would argue that there are sufficient numbers of actively managed funds that do it," Curtis says.

Curtis also says the large capitalisation stock bias of Australian index funds exposes them to higher risk. She says while these biases are evident in active funds, the difference is that in the active funds, the biases are intended and are aimed at adding value.

Curtis argues that index investing indicates a belief that the market is efficient and that it is therefore impossible to add value by identifying mispriced securities and tilting away from the index.

"Index managers argue that even if markets are not fully efficient, it can be difficult to identify active managers who can add value," she says.

She adds that index funds also point to the higher fees charged by active funds as a point in favour of the passive styled investing.

But statistics released by Partnership Planning on performance by the median fund managers and upper quartile fund managers tell a different story, even after the higher fees are factored out of the return equation.

Median returns have equalled or outperformed the index over the past 10 years, while managers in the upper quartile have outperformed the All Ordinaries index by more than five per cent.

Curtis believes Partnership Planning has refuted the argument by index funds that it is difficult to choose managers who consistently add value in its selection of a blend of three managers which since July 1996 has outperformed the All Ords by up to 10 per cent.

Read more about:

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

MARKET INSIGHTS

This verdict highlights something deeply wrong and rotten at the heart of the FSCP. We are witnessing a heavy-handed, op...

4 days 17 hours ago

Interesting. Would be good to know the details of the StrategyOne deal....

1 week 1 day ago

It’s astonishing to see the FAAA now pushing for more advisers by courting "career changers" and international recruits,...

4 weeks ago

Insignia Financial has made four appointments, including three who have joined from TAL, to lead strategy and innovation in its retirement solutions for the MLC brand....

3 weeks 1 day ago

A former Brisbane financial adviser has been charged with 26 counts of dishonest conduct regarding a failure to disclose he would receive substantial commission payments ...

1 week ago

Pinnacle Investment Management has announced it will acquire strategic interests in two international fund managers for $142 million....

1 week ago