Regulatory objectivity vital


Editorial Comment
Much as a judge or magistrate has a duty to stay impartial when hearing matters which come before their courts, so too does a Commonwealth regulator have a duty to remain objective.
Thus, the sweeping and emotive language used about financial planners by the chairman of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), Greg Medcraft, in answering questions at the National Press Club last week was inappropriate and arguably raises questions about the regulator's ability to be seen as fair and objective.
Medcraft's seemingly emotive response to questions asked about financial planners is explicable in the context of a year during which much attention was focused on the enforceable undertakings imposed on Commonwealth Financial Planning and Macquarie, but seemed to ignore the manner in which those events were leveraged by the political forces who mounted the campaign against the Government's Future of Financial Advice (FOFA) changes.
Further, intentionally or not, his comments served to tarnish the reputations of many highly ethical and hard-working financial planners while diminishing the achievements of the Financial Planning Association (FPA) and Association of Financial Advisers (AFA) in seeking to lift standards and rid the sector of bad apples.
Mr Medcraft is not a career public servant. If he were, he would likely have stuck to a carefully-prepared script and tempered any comments capable of giving rise to perceptions of bias.
The ASIC chairman is entitled to his personal views about the financial planning industry, but his comments at the National Press Club would be seen by many as having not only unfairly tarnished an entire profession but as having diminished his own office.
- Mike Taylor
Recommended for you
Money Management examines the share price of financial advice licensees over one year to 31 March, with M&A actions in the final quarter having a positive effect for two licensees.
A $3.5 million settlement for victims of Melissa Caddick has been approved by the Federal Court following an initial agreement last December.
The Reserve Bank of Australia has delivered its first rate decision since the introduction of a new board structure last month.
Digital advice provider Otivo has launched an interactive tool, powered by artificial intelligence and Otivo’s own advice engine, to help answer client questions.