Planners lash out at soft dollar taxing plans
Financial planning dealer groups have hit out at plans by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) to target a new public register of soft dollar commission payments.
As reported by Money Management last week, the ATO is considering whether to monitor the register where financial planners will have to disclose any soft dollar payments they receive from January 1, 2005.
Fiducian Financial Services managing director Indy Singh told Money Management the idea of monitoring the register with a view to taxing soft dollar payments is misguided.
Planners must already declare some soft dollar payments via income tax returns, and Singh says the ATO’s plan to reap revenue by hitting the soft dollar register could prove fruitless.
“My question to the ATO is ‘how is it being hidden?’” he says.
Singh says the ATO would be better placed to consider where most of the soft dollar commissions come from.
“Much of these soft dollar cruises and airfares comes from the big end of town — none of the small people can afford to do it,” Singh says.
Aon Financial Planning and Protection managing director Greg Dunger says industry groups like the Financial Planning Association (FPA) need to take the issue up with the ATO to seek clarification on the possible implications of the crackdown.
“The problem is you’re putting a tax issue and a legislative issue into a washing machine and swishing them around. It’s like putting in something that’s red and something that’s white and both of them coming out pink,” Dunger says.
Both the FPA and the Investment and Financial Services Association (IFSA), which drew up plans for the register, have confirmed they are in ongoing discussions with the ATO on the matter.
The associations created the register as part of a new industry code of practice to counter intense public criticism over soft dollar payments in the financial planning industry.
But Dunger says news of the planned tax crackdown could hurt efforts to clean up soft dollar payments in the financial planning industry.
“There are certain ways of looking after consumers, but if you’re going to bring in a draconian type approach to tax on it, then are you really rewarding people for the right behaviour?” Dunger says.
Singh agrees any move by the ATO could derail the industry’s work on soft dollar disclosure.
“They have actually wound it back to square one again,” he says.
Recommended for you
After seven years at the company, Iress’ chief technology officer for wealth management APAC, Anthony Gerrits, has departed as the firm commences a search process to fill the role.
With advice firms thinking about scaling up in 2025, research has detailed the main avenues financial advisers say they have used for successful recruitment.
The board of Insignia Financial has reached a decision regarding the possible acquisition of the firm by US private equity giant Bain Capital.
Six of the seven listed financial advice licensees have reported positive share price growth in 2024, with AMP and Insignia successfully reversing earlier losses.
