Grandfathering – ASIC relied on sample-based data
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has admitted that it only had sample-sized data when it made some of its initial pronouncements on the negative impacts of grandfathered commission arrangements for financial advisers.
In evidence to the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Corporations and Financial Services, ASIC executive, Joanna Bird sought to defend the regulator against suggestions from Queensland Liberal back-bencher, Bert Van Manen that the regulator had no comprehensive idea about the situation before it had begun collecting data as a result of an instruction from the Treasurer, Josh Frydenberg.
Bird said that ASIC had done earlier work where it had looked at grandfathering but that there had been huge variations because the exercises had been “just samples”.
“We thought grandfathered commissions were having a negative impact,” she said.
She said it was therefore wrong to suggest that ASIC had not done any work, but it was now doing that work in an extremely comprehensive manner because the regulator had received a direction under the ASIC Act from the Treasurer.
“But that is not to suggest we had no data prior to that,” Bird said.
Van Manen placed a number of questions on notice to ASIC on the issue of grandfathering including the total amount invested in grandfathered funds, how many advisers would be impacted, the total amount of grandfathered commissions, the total amount of volume bonuses and shelf spaced fees and what consideration had been given to clients who couldn’t be moved because of factors such as exit fees, Capital Gains Tax, insurance etc.
Former Productivity Commission (PC) deputy chair and newly-appointed ASIC deputy chair, Karen Chester told the committee that much more work had been done by the PC which had identified the extent of grandfathered commissions and which had then been used as a resource by the Royal Commissioner, Kenneth Hayne.
Recommended for you
A relevant provider has received a written direction from the Financial Services and Credit Panel after a superannuation rollover resulted in tax bill of over $200,000 for a client.
Estimates for the calendar year 2024 put the advice industry on track for a loss in adviser numbers as exits offset gains from new entrants.
Adviser Ratings shares five ways that financial advice changed in 2024 with an optimistic outlook for 2025, thanks to the Delivering Better Financial Outcomes legislation.
National advice firm Invest Blue has announced several acquisitions, including the purchase of an estate planning and wealth protection business Lambert Group.
