Funds obscure performance
Armstrong Jones chief investment officer David McClatchy reckons that a number of New Zealand share funds are disguising their true performance by investing in Australian shares while keeping a NZSE benchmark.
McClatchy says many NZ equity funds have changed their mandates so they can invest in Australia, yet they continue to use NZSE indices as benchmarks.
"It's absolute nonsense," he says. "You can't tell whether (a manager) is doing a great job."
This creep has lead to an increasingly wider range of returns reported by so-called NZ equity funds.
Also this creep has hit AJ's locally domiciled unit trust which continues to invest solely in New Zealand. Over the years its ranking against its peers has fallen, while the range of returns reported by NZ share funds has increased.
AJ is taking the high moral ground on this issue with the launch of its own Australasian share fund (which is an UK-based open-ended investment company managed by Edinburgh Fund Managers).
McClatchy says the fund is benchmarked against a composite index which is 50 per cent NZSE40 and 50 per cent ASX200.
The company studied various ways of developing a suitable benchmark including having one which was weighted on the relevant capitalisation of each market (such a benchmark would be heavily in Australia's favour as its market capitalisation is about A$700 billion compared to $42 billion in New Zealand).
Instead the benchmark was worked out on what would have provided the best performance over the past 20 years.
McClatchy says their research revealed that New Zealand had marginally outperformed Australia over the last two decades.
On an unhedged basis the optimal mix was 60:40 to New Zealand. However, on a hedged basis the result was the other way around. McClatchy says that a 50:50 mix was "a prudent starting point".
Recommended for you
The Federal Court has made interim travel restraint orders against two Falcon Capital directors, while also freezing one director’s assets.
For the 2025 financial year, all but one listed advice licensee has reported double-digit share price growth – but which licensee has seen the best performance and what activities have they enacted during the period?
Evidentia Group has confirmed its new executive leadership structure, having been formed from the merger between Evidentia and Lonsec Investment Solutions, to shape the future of managed accounts.
CC Capital, the last remaining player in the bid to acquire Insignia Financial, is still yet to finalise its offer, the firm has informed the market.
