FSI will do nothing to change status quo
The Financial System Inquiry (FSI) will not change anything and the status quo will be maintained, according to a finance/insurance broker.
Self-employed Australian financial services licence holder Tony Canvin said there will be oblique observations made about the way things have panned out with events like Storm Financial, but nothing will change.
Canvin, who worked for merchant and investment banks like the First Boston Corporation until the 1990s, said the fact that the head of the inquiry, David Murray, was once the head of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia shows that it is "the inmates in the asylum investigating themselves".
"The banks will have, if you like, the vertical integration they've got now, which to me is just amazing that it has arisen and has been allowed to rise," he said.
Vertical integration should be taken to task, and it should be proven that things like the Storm Financial collapse was a direct result of it, he said.
"If the Commonwealth Bank had had its way it would've bought Storm way back then. Now it's got its Storm. You can imagine what the next tragedy's going to be like."
"Conflicts of interest, whether they are there or not, appear to be there. The fact that they own financial advisors who give ‘independent financial advice' to people who are looking for that independent advice...it beggars belief that an investment advisor wouldn't be selling the bank's products.
Canvin believes any review should get down to the fundamentals and separate the bankers from the fund managers.
"Once you move from that you've got to say if an investment adviser is an adviser, he must be truly independent; therefore not obligated to anybody about anything. He must be able to be free from the leverage of employment, and give complete independent advice."
He also believes the legislation should set out a framework where the banks, fund managers and insurance companies should not be interdependent upon each other.
AUTHOR
Malavika Santhebennur
Recommended for you
A third private equity player has emerged in the bidding war to acquire Insignia Financial, rivalling Bain Capital and CC Capital.
The proportion of advisers working at a privately owned licensee rose to 78 per cent in the fourth quarter of 2024 as over 1,000 advisers left a diversified firm.
Advice around a client’s concessional contribution cap was the reason for the latest written direction by the Financial Services and Credit Panel.
The financial advice business has expanded its range of services with the introduction of Apt Wealth Legal Services to meet clients’ evolving needs in estate planning and family law.
