ASIC only successful after damage is done
The man who is chairing the Senate Committee reviewing the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has declared that the regulator's greatest successes appear to have occurred after money has been lost.
Tasmanian Liberal Senator, David Bushby, has used an address to the Risk Management Association in Melbourne to say that one of the anticipated outcomes of the Senate Committee inquiry "will be an assessment of the effectiveness of ASIC when it comes to making best use of its regulatory tools, particularly with a view to considering ‘over the horizon' intelligence to prevent failure".
In doing so, he said there were many questions in relation to "the effectiveness of ASIC's enforcement of the law on financial products and advice that will need to be explored by the inquiry".
Bushby pointed to the recent high-profile failures in regulation of financial advice including Storm Financial, Trio/Astarra and the enforceable undertaking imposed on Commonwealth Financial Planning, and allegations that whistle-blowers had been ignored by the regulators.
He said it was possible to identify some common threads from the failures:
* Product complexity made it difficult for consumers to make rational and informed decisions;
* Financial advisers engaged in promoting products not appropriate to client needs; and
* Regulatory intelligence, forensic skill and enforcement appears to have been lacking — as the regulation activity occurred well after the event.
"The supporters of Future of Financial Advice (FOFA) would argue that in relation to the first and second of these points — product complexity and mis-selling — we are now better prepared," Bushby said. "However, the reality is that there is little in FOFA that would have had any impact on any of these failures.
"To avoid losses occasioned by these sort of failures, we need to consider the role of regulation in addressing issues before the event in combating product and sales excesses, as opposed to mopping up after the event," he said. "Again, regulation itself isn't necessarily the problem — it is ensuring that the regulation applied is appropriate and workable, delivering benefits that outweigh the costs."
Recommended for you
With an advice M&A deal taking around six months to enact, two experts have shared their tips on how buyers and sellers can avoid “deal fatigue” and prevent potential deals from collapsing.
Several financial advisers have been shortlisted in the ninth annual Women in Finance Awards 2025, to be held on 14 November.
Digital advice tools are on the rise, but licensees will need to ensure they still meet adviser obligations or potentially risk a class action if clients lose money from a rogue algorithm.
Shaw and Partners has merged with Sydney wealth manager Kennedy Partners Wealth, while Ord Minnett has hired a private wealth adviser from Morgan Stanley.
