AAT backflips on appeal of banned adviser
The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) is upholding the Australian Securities and Investments Commission’s (ASIC) decision to ban former financial adviser Tony Davidof from providing financial advice for three years, after previously upholding a counter appeal.
Money Management previously reported that the AAT upheld an appeal by Davidof against the regulator’s decision to ban him after he was found to have engaged in manipulation of the price of MINI warrants - a type of derivative product traded on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX), issued by Credit Suisse.
The decision against Davidof’s conduct that resulted in his ban in October 2015 followed investigation into the price manipulation events, which occurred in December 2012 and February 2013.
“The prices at which Davidof and another former employee were trading MINIs in 2013 were designed to transfer the profit/loss from all the preceding trading, without reflecting the SPI Futures that were actually traded and this was likely to have the effect of creating an artificial price for trading in the affected MINIs on the ASX,” Money Management reported in January.
The AAT has today affirmed the seriousness of the breach of conduct by both Davidof and former Credit Suisse employee, Philip McLean and acknowledged of the contravening of the Corporations Act 2001.
Davidof called for a review into ASIC’s decision to ban him from providing financial advice for a period of three years in January 2016, after the AAT upheld Davidof’s October 2015 appeal on the basis of MINIs not being defined as a financial product.
The Federal Court of Australia upheld ASIC’s finding appeal that MINIs were a financial product in June this year, and referred the matter back to the AAT.
“Mr Davidof was aware…that the forces of supply and demand did not govern the impugned transactions. He admits that they were designed only to transfer a profit or loss arising from other transactions,” the AAT said.
“Market manipulation is prohibited in order to further the objects of promoting confident and informed decision making by consumers of financial products and services, and fair, orderly and transparent markets for financial products.”
Credit Suisse ceased the trade of MINIs in October 2013.
AUTHOR
Hope William-Smith
Recommended for you
Sequoia Financial Group has declined by five financial advisers in the past week, four of whom have opened up a new AFSL, according to Wealth Data.
Insignia Financial chief executive Scott Hartley has detailed whether the firm will be selecting an exclusive bidder for the second phase of due diligence as it awaits revised bids from three private equity players.
Insignia Financial has reported a statutory net loss after tax of $17 million in its first half results, although the firm has noted cost optimisation means this is an improvement from a $50 million loss last year.
With alternative funds being described as “impossible” for fund managers to target towards advisers without the support of BDMs for education, Money Management explores the evolving nature of the distribution role.
