A presumption of guilt without evidence?

peter kell ASIC financial advisers financial services council financial advice life insurance money management australian securities and investments commission FSC director chairman

22 March 2013
| By Staff |
image
image
expand image

“If you don’t think financial advice on life insurance is a problem area for ASIC and for industry, please think again.” 

It must be assumed that if Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) commissioner, Peter Kell, took the trouble to say this to a packed Money Management/Financial Services Council function last week, then it was based on hard facts. 

It is therefore worth noting that Kell went on to say: “A number of our major surveillances resulting in licensing conditions, enforceable undertakings and, most seriously, licence revocations, involved evidence of significant amounts of inappropriate advice on life insurance”. 

Unfortunately, Kell did not go on to detail the numbers of times or dates during which these things occurred, giving rise to a not unreasonable call by Synchron director Don Trapnell for the regulator to provide the statistical and other proof that life/risk churning is, indeed, a problem. 

Over the past nine months Money Management has closely followed the debate on life/risk churn generated by the announcement of the Financial Services Council’s (FSC’s) guidelines issued at its 2012 annual conference, including the use of claw-back provisions.

Numerous attempts were made to gain industry consensus around that framework but, earlier this year, it was acknowledged that none had been achieved. 

Fundamental to the difficulty in finding common ground on the issue of life/risk churn was the absence of any real agreement about a statistical basis for measuring the incidence of such practices or, indeed, any agreement about what could actually be regarded as churn. 

While the FSC chairman, John Brogden, last week referenced data around lapse rates, a number of insurance company executives had earlier told a Money Management roundtable that care needed to be taken in interpreting lapse rate data in circumstances where policies could be allowed to lapse for a number of reasons totally unconnected to churn. 

Given all of this, there is a real need for ASIC to back up its concerns around life/risk churn with evidence which can be both analysed and accepted by those large sections of the industry who believe that if a problem actually exists, it involves only a very small number of advisers. 

Given’s Kell’s admonition to last week’s event, the FSC’s John Brogden is right when he suggests that if the industry does not successfully self-regulate on the question of churn, then the regulator will step in to impose itself. 

However Synchron’s Don Trapnell is also correct in making his call for the production of evidence regarding the scale of the problem. 

In the absence of that evidence, many advisers can justifiably lay claim to being denied the presumption of innocence.  

Read more about:

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

MARKET INSIGHTS

GG

So shareholders lose a dividend plus have seen the erosion of value. Qantas decides to clawback remuneration from Alan ...

2 months 2 weeks ago
Denise Baker

This is why I left my last position. There was no interest in giving the client quality time, it was all about bumping ...

2 months 2 weeks ago
gonski

So the Hayne Royal Commission has left us with this. What a sad day for the financial planning industry. Clearly most ...

2 months 2 weeks ago

A Sydney-based financial adviser has been banned from providing financial services in the interest of consumer protection after failing to act on conduct concerns. ...

4 weeks 1 day ago

Insignia Financial has made four appointments, including three who have joined from TAL, to lead strategy and innovation in its retirement solutions for the MLC brand....

3 days 7 hours ago

ASIC has cancelled the AFSL of a $250 million Sydney fund manager, one of two AFSL cancellations announced by the corporate regulator....

3 weeks 6 days ago