Margin lending profits inflated: Walker

insurance gearing margin lending ANZ director

8 July 1999
| By Samantha Walker |

Profits for margin lending providers are artificially high, according to an industry figure.

Mercer Fund Manager Services principal Geoff Walker says if the loss experience of players in the gearing market is substantial enough to justify the current rates, then the players should let the market know.

He says the gearing market shares similar characteristics to the home loan market, and therefore prices should reflect this. Furthermore, the market is ripe, he says, for a discount lender to force profit margins down as has happened in the home loan market.

However, Deutsche Funds Management director Sarah Brennan argues Walker is "not comparing apples with apples" by likening the two markets. She argues that lending in shares contains a greater risk.

"Share values go up and down on a daily basis, and you don't have this volatility with the housing market," she says.

"If a client doesn't meet a margin call and you have to sell the shares, there is not always a market to sell them at sufficient recovery costs," she says.

Brennan also says that the margin lending market does not have mortgage insurance like the home loan market.

ANZ Margin Lending marketing manager Sarah Frearson backs Brennan's argument. She says the two markets are distinct, with margin lenders incurring huge administrative costs in comparison to the home loan market. She also argues that, unlike most margin lenders, home lenders slug clients with establishment and ongoing fees.

However, while Walker says he applauds the gearing market for their high level of customer service, he argues the extra administration should be reducing risk.

Furthermore, he says the market is not lending against high risk shares.

"While I accept that there is the potential for volatility in a sharemarket, gearing managers lend often lend against managed funds, which generally carry less risk than direct shares," he says.

Read more about:

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

MARKET INSIGHTS

Completely agree Peter. The definition of 'significant change is circumstances relevant to the scope of the advice' is s...

2 months ago

This verdict highlights something deeply wrong and rotten at the heart of the FSCP. We are witnessing a heavy-handed, op...

2 months ago

Interesting. Would be good to know the details of the StrategyOne deal....

2 months 1 week ago

SuperRatings has shared the median estimated return for balanced superannuation funds for the calendar year 2024, finding the year achieved “strong and consistent positiv...

3 weeks 2 days ago

Original bidder Bain Capital, which saw its first offer rejected in December, has returned with a revised bid for Insignia Financial....

2 weeks 2 days ago

The FAAA has secured CSLR-related documents under the FOI process, after an extended four-month wait, which show little analysis was done on how the scheme’s cost would a...

1 week 6 days ago

TOP PERFORMING FUNDS