ASIC comes out of the shadows
So the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) intends to conduct another financial planning shadow shopping exercise some time after June 30, this year — meaning there will have been a two-year gap between such efforts on the part of the regulator.
No one in the financial planning industry should be surprised by the ASIC action. The regulator made clear last year that such an exercise would be scheduled, not least because it was something supported by the then newly-elected Rudd Labor Government.
Equally unsurprising should have been the fact that the first organisation to comment on the 2009-10 ASIC shadow shop was the Industry Super Network, with its executive manager, David Whitely, calling on the regulator to extend its efforts beyond simple compliance to whether advice is being provided in the ‘best interests’ of the client.
Of course, the environment in which the shadow shop is conducted will be very different to that which existed in 2005 and 2006. Investment returns have collapsed and as our front-page story reveals, financial planners are feeling extreme stress.
If the shadow shopping exercise is to have any meaning at all, it must traverse the entire financial planning industry, and that includes planners working for or on behalf of industry superannuation funds. Perhaps, too, the regulator’s shadow shoppers could try sampling the efforts of some of the call centre ‘advisers’ to whom super fund members are referred when they ask to transfer their balances into cash.
What ASIC ought to understand is that the financial planning industry has evolved since its last shadow shopping exercise and fund-related planners represent a significant part of that evolution. Connection to an industry fund does not carry with it impunity from appropriate regulatory oversight.
ASIC under the leadership of chairman Michael D’Aloisio is a less abrasive organisation than the body that was led by his predecessor, Jeff Lucy. It is to be hoped, on that basis, that the regulator adopts a more measured approach to any enforcement action evolving out of the shadow shopping exercise.
For this latest shadow shopping exercise to have legitimacy it must focus on compliance, not political agendas.
By Mike Taylor
AUTHOR
Mike Taylor
Recommended for you
In this week’s episode of Relative Return Insider, hosts Maja Garaca Djurdjevic and Keith Ford take a look at the Reserve Bank’s expectation-defying interest rate hold and whether the move is the start of a fundamental change in the central bank’s approach.
In this week’s episode of Relative Return Insider, hosts Maja Garaca Djurdjevic and Keith Ford break down the flurry of activity and announcements since the calendar ticked over to FY26, from ASIC action to super fund results.
In this week’s episode of Relative Return Insider, AMP chief economist Shane Oliver joins the show to explore the major global and domestic forces shaping investment markets in 2025, from ongoing geopolitical tensions and the NATO summit to US President Donald Trump’s trade policy and the One Big Beautiful Bill.
In this week’s episode of Relative Return Insider, Professor Robert Brooks of Monash Business School joins the show to unpack the economic and market implications of rising tensions between Israel and Iran.
